top of page

Menu

Gourmet Cheesecake @ The City Market



Year-Round Flavors




Turtle Pecan

Our signature slice: an absolutely irresistible kaleidoscope of cheesecake, caramel, chocolate, and locally grown Brunswick pecans! (Whole cake = 12 slices, pre-order only) (Slices served in-person only at City Market KC)

Single Slice

$8.49


Whole Cake

$79.99

Turtle Pecan


Pecan Pie (whole cake only)

Only in "The Pecan Capital of Missouri" can you get this delicious cheesecake: pecan pie filling suspended in cheesecake and topped with whipped topping and local Brunswick pecans. (Whole cake = 14 slices, pre-order only)

Whole Cake

$75.99

Pecan Pie (whole cake only)


Classic Créme (Brûlée)

Our New York-style slice with golden graham cracker crust—a blank canvas for any kind of topping! (Plus, you can get it brûlée'd at the shop!) (Whole cake = 14 slices, pre-order only) (Slices served in-person only at City Market KC)

Single Slice

$7.99


Whole Cake

$79.99

Classic Créme (Brûlée)


Royal Raspberry Swirl

We leveled up our plain slice with dazzling swirls of black raspberry sauce, and the crust is gluten-friendly, too! (Whole cake = 12 slices, pre-order only) (Slices served in-person only at City Market KC)

Single Slice

$7.99


Whole Cake

$75.99

Gluten-friendly
Gluten-friendly
Royal Raspberry Swirl


White Chocolate Raspberry (whole cake only)

Luxury you can eat: Raspberries and white chocolate swirled in a creamy white chocolate cheesecake, topped with raspberries and a white chocolate cheesecake mousse, finished off with whipped topping and white chocolate bark. (Whole cake = 14 slices, pre-order only)

Whole Cake

$99.99

Gluten-friendly
Gluten-friendly
White Chocolate Raspberry (whole cake only)


German Chocolate (whole cake only)

Our local Brunswick pecans combine with toasted coconut in a luscious frosting that is layered in creamy chocolate cheesecake and finished off with even more coconut, Brunswick pecans, and a dark chocolate drizzle. (Whole cake = 14 slices, pre-order only)

Whole Cake

$99.99

German Chocolate (whole cake only)


Deep Dark Chocolate

The richness of Belgian dark chocolate is the hero of this slice, with silky textures that keep you coming back for more and more! (Whole cake = 12 slices, pre-order only) (Slices served in-person only at City Market KC)

Single Slice

$7.99


Whole Cake

$75.99

Deep Dark Chocolate


Cookies and Cream

Who said only milk could have a favorite cookie? This best-selling slice is proud and unapologetic with its ultra-rich level of Oreo® cookies! (Whole cake = 14 slices; pre-order only) (Slices served in-person only at City Market KC)

Single Slice

$7.99


Whole Cake

$75.99

Cookies and Cream


Peanut Butter Blast

Peanut butter lovers unite! We’ve packed this slice chock-full of Reese’s® chunks and peanut butter—even the frosting has it, too! (Whole cake = 14 slices, pre-order only) (Slices served in-person only at City Market KC)

Single Slice

$7.99


Whole Cake

$75.99

Peanut Butter Blast


Kit & Caboodle (whole cake only)

"One of each!" A taste of all our flavors! (Whole cake = 12 slices, pre-order only)

Whole Cake

$79.99

Kit & Caboodle (whole cake only)


The Favorites (whole cake only)

Turtle Pecan, Royal Raspberry Swirl, Pecan Pie, and Classic Crème (Brûlée). (Whole cake = 12 slices, pre-order only)

Whole Cake

$79.99

The Favorites (whole cake only)



Seasonal Flavors




Summer Lime

Beat the heat with the instant cool of our Summer Lime slice! It’s bright... It’s sweet... It’s refreshing... It’s the perfect bite to enjoy on a warm day! (Whole cake = 14 slices, pre-order only) (Slices served in-person only at City Market KC) (Summer only)

Single Slice

$7.99


Whole Cake

$75.99

Summer Lime


Pumpkin

The smooth texture of cheesecake with a blend of classic spices and locally grown pumpkins (roasted and puréed in the shop!), is the perfect way to enjoy a crisp Fall day! (Whole cake = 12 slices, pre-order only) (Slices served in-person only at City Market KC) (Fall only)

Single Slice

$7.99


Whole Cake

$75.99

Pumpkin


Dutch Apple (whole cake only)

Locally grown apples and cinnamon meld with creamy cheesecake and are topped off with a crumb topping and homemade salted caramel sauce. (Whole cake = 14 slices, pre-order only) (Fall only)

Whole Cake

$75.99

Gluten-friendly
Gluten-friendly
Dutch Apple (whole cake only)


Peppermint White Chocolate

Fresh peppermint combines with creamy cheesecake swirled with white chocolate ganache topped with white chocolate peppermint mousse, whipped topping, and a shard of white chocolate bark. (Whole cake = 14 slices, pre-order only) (Slices served in-person only at City Market KC) (Winter only)

Single Slice

$7.99


Whole Cake

$75.99

Peppermint White Chocolate


Red Velvet

This bold, red cheesecake topped with whipped cream cheese frosting just dares you to take a bite! (Whole cake = 14 slices, pre-order only) (Slices served in-person only at City Market KC) (Winter only)

Single Slice

$7.99


Whole Cake

$75.99

Red Velvet

Open Tuesday–Saturday, 10:00am–4:00pm

Vendor booth @CityMarketKC Saturdays, 8:00am–3:00pm (hours vary seasonally)

Closed the week before the 4th of July, Thanksgiving Day, Christmas Day and the week following

660-548-3600

121 E Broadway St, Brunswick, MO 65236

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Trip Advisor
  • Yelp

 

© 2025 by Kaitlynn's. Powered and secured by Wix 

 

bottom of page