top of page

Kaitlynn's ​Cheesecakes

Handmade in House by Kaitlynn herself!

- A rotating selection is available in store -

Need Gluten-Friendly Options? Check out our Gluten-Friendly cheesecakes! (G-Friendly)

While our Gluten-Friendly cheesecakes do not contain gluten ingredients, they are made in our kitchen with other cheesecakes that are, so there’s always a possibility of cross-contamination, and so indirect contact to gluten is possible. 

*Depending on your sensitivity to gluten, many of our cheesecakes have gluten only in the crust. (G. Crust)

Turtle Pecan ~ An irresistible combination of cheesecake, homemade caramel, gourmet chocolate, and locally grown pecans with more on top! 79.99  12 slices  (G. Crust)

Oreo ~ Oreo Overload! Oreo crust, creamy Oreo cheesecake, whipped topping, and more Oreo! 75.99 14 slices

Pecan Pie ~  Only in "The Pecan Capital of Missouri" can you git this delicious cheesecake; a pecan pie suspended in cheesecake and topped with whipped topping and local pecans. 79.99 12 slices (G. Crust)

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup ~ Reese's surrounded by smooth peanut buttery cheesecake topped off with our peanut butter frosting. 75.99 14 slices (G. Crust)

Crème Brûlée ~  Our version of "plain" cheesecake, this creamy cheesecake is baked on a golden crust of graham crackers and when served to enjoy at Kaitlynn's, topped with caramelized sugar or enjoy it with
 strawberry topping. 79.9

14 slices (G. Crust)

Deep Dark Chocolate ~ Darkly rich, Belgium dark chocolate makes this cheesecake a must for chocolate lovers! 75.99

12 slices (G. Crust)

German Chocolate ~ Our local Brunswick pecans combine with toasted coconut in a luscious frosting that is layered in creamy chocolate cheesecake and finished off with even more coconut, Brunswick pecans, and a dark chocolate drizzle. 99.99 14 slices (G. Crust)

Blackberry Swirl ~ The deep flavor of blackberry makes this gorgeous cheesecake taste even better than it looks. 75.99

12 slices (G-Friendly)


Chocolate Mousse ~ A decadently airy, Belgian chocolate cheesecake with whipped topping to finish it off. 75.99

12 slices (G-Friendly)

Caramel Mocha ~ Locally roasted coffee, chocolate, and homemade caramel are layered together in this smooth cheesecake and finished with coffee chocolate mousse, caramel, whipped topping, a chocolate curl, and chocolate-covered espresso bean. 99.99 14 slices (G. Crust)

Red Velvet ~ This bold red cheesecake topped with a whipped cream cheese frosting just dares you to take a bite of its velvety, chocolate cheesecake flavor that is only found in red velvet! 75.99 12 slices (G. Crust)

Butterfinger ~ Butterfingers make this a winning combination of crunchy, chocolatey peanut butter and rich, creamy cheesecake. 75.99 12 slices (G. Crust)

Raspberry White Chocolate ~ Kaitlynn's 10 Year Celebration Flavor! ~ Raspberries and white chocolate swirled in a creamy white chocolate cheesecake, topped with raspberries and a white chocolate cheesecake mousse, finished off with whipped topping and white chocolate bark. 99.99 14 slices (G-Friendly)


- Want to enjoy a whole cheesecake! Call or order online to reserve your flavor now! -

Variety ​Cheesecakes

12 Hand-selected Favorites!


The Favorites ~ Turtle Pecan, Crème Brûlée, Blackberry Swirl, Pecan Pie. 79.99

The Kit & Caboodle ~ "One of Each!" A taste of all our flavors! 86.99

​Seasonal Flavors


Pistachio ~ Smooth cheesecake combined with crunchy toasted pistachios and topped with a homemade Pistachio brittle. 79.99

14 slices (G-Friendly)

Lemon Blueberry ~ Lemon and wild blueberries come together in a springtime cheesecake made with artesian Fromage Blanc Cheese from Edgewood Creamery in Purdy, MO, and topped with homemade lemon curd mousse and candied lemon. 82.99

14 slices (G. Crust)

Carrot Cake  ~  Rich carrot cake swirled in creamy cheesecake and finished off with our pineapple cream cheese frosting. 79.99  14 slices



SummerLime ~ A delightfully refreshing cheesecake! Lime combines with cheesecake to make a cool, tangy dessert. 75.99

12 slices (G. Crust)


Pumpkin ~ Bring the flavor of the holidays to the table with this cheesecake made with locally grown pumpkin! 75.99

 12 slices (G. Crust)


Dutch Apple ~ Locally grown apples and cinnamon meld with creamy cheesecake and are topped off with a crumb topping

and homemade salted caramel sauce. 75.99 14 slices (G-Friendly)


Peppermint White Chocolate  ~ Fresh peppermint combines with creamy cheesecake swirled with white chocolate ganache topped with white chocolate peppermint mousse, whipped topping, and a shard of white chocolate bark. 75.99 14 slices (G. Crust)

Valentine Cheesecakes

A cheesecake for two!

These little cheesecakes are the perfect way to say "I love you!"

Turtle Pecan, Red Velvet, Deep Dark Chocolate, Blackberry Swirl, Reese's Peanut Butter Cup, Crème Brûlée, Oreo, Caramel Mocha. 

(Available to pick-up at the shop Valentines week)

Tuesday - Saturday 10am - 4pm

  • Facebook - Black Circle
  • TripAdvisor - Black Circle
  • Instagram - Black Circle
  • Yelp - Black Circle
bottom of page